An international group of twelve experts recently published a consensus report examining the state of the evidence and offering recommendations to guide the screening, diagnosis, and treatment of individuals with ADHD-SUD comorbidity.
In a clear sign that we are still in the early stages of understanding this relationship, five of the thirteen recommendations received the lowest recommendation grade (D), eight received the next-lowest (C), and none received the highest (A and B). The lower grades reflected the absence of the highest level of evidence, obtained from meta-analyses or systematic reviews of relevant randomized controlled trials (RCTs).
Nevertheless, with these limitations in mind, the experts agreed on the following points:
- The strongest recommendation, the only one based on a 2+ level of evidence (well-conducted case-control or cohort studies with allowing risk of confounding or bias and a moderate probability that the relationship is causal) is that the "Short Version of the Adult ADHD Self-Report Scale (ASRS-SV) screener is currently the most widely used and investigated screening tool in individuals with ADHD and comorbid SUD, with good sensitivity and specificity across studies."
- Two other recommendations were graded C: The diagnostic process should include current and past substance abuse, and seek to involve partners and relatives in evaluating symptoms and functional impairments.
- Four recommendations got the lowest grade, D. The experts suggested starting the diagnostic process as soon as possible and focusing on drug- and alcohol-free periods in the patient's life during history taking. They also recommended that physicians and clinical psychologists should only make diagnoses if they have extensive training in diagnosing ADHD, as well as experience with adults with ADHD and with addiction care, and that they should consider treating adults with sufficiently severe ADHD symptoms.
- In general, evidence was stronger in this area, and only one of the six recommendations was graded D. The other five recommendations were graded C, with the highest level of evidence being 2(cohort or case and control studies with undetermined risk of bias), although in three cases it was level 3 (non-analytical studies, such as case reports and case series).
- The grade D recommendation was to always consider a combination of psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy.
The grade C recommendations included considering adequate medical treatment of both ADHD and SUD; integrating ADHD treatment with SUD treatment as soon as possible;
Cleo L. Crunelle at al., "InternationalConsensus Statement on Screening, Diagnosis and Treatment of Substance UseDisorder Patients with Comorbid Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder," European Addiction Research, publishedonline March 6, 2018, DOI: 10.1159/000487767.